Battle lines drawn as industry reacts to leasehold reforms

Img

Stakeholders across the property industry have responded to the government’s Leasehold and Commonhold Reform Bill, setting out some of the arguments likely to shape lobbying as it passes through Parliament.

The National Leasehold Campaign was among the first to welcome the proposals, but cautioned that much would depend on the detail of the legislation and how the changes are implemented.

NLC co-founder Cath Williams says: “As this Bill passes through Parliament, there is no doubt that those who have profited from the leasehold system will lobby hard to protect their interests.

“The government must not be distracted by that noise.

“It must remain focused on delivering for the millions of leaseholders who have spent years fighting for change, not those who have milked the system for far too long.

“This is a once-in-a-generation opportunity to end one of the greatest injustices in homeownership.

“Ministers must hold their nerve and finish the job.”

Concerns over building maintenance

Martyn Gerrard Estate Agents chairman Simon Gerrard warns that making it harder to recover service charges and legal costs could affect building maintenance.

He says: “Buildings cannot be maintained on transparency alone.

“Service charges will become harder for the freeholder to recover, meaning works cannot be carried out and the building will fall into disrepair.

“This will only be exacerbated under commonhold, as even where legal action is taken, the cost of recovering the money could exceed the amount being pursued due to proposed legislation removing the ability to recover legal costs.

“Being a freeholder of a block of flats or an owner under commonhold will become a liability, eroding the value of the entire building against a backdrop of an already falling market.

“It’s worth remembering that one of the main drivers of rising service charges is the growing burden of statutory reports and other compliance requirements.

“Every case is nuanced, but the government is trying to wave a magic wand over a highly complex issue.”

Valuation disputes and legal challenges

Search Acumen managing director Andrew Lloyd says the transition from leasehold to commonhold could create additional complexity for property lawyers and transactions.

He says: “The government has set the direction of travel for leasehold to become a legacy tenure, and commonhold to become the preferred ownership model.

“The transition period will create complexity.

“In the short term, this may lead to more valuation disputes in transactions involving investor-owned freeholds, large London mansion blocks, mixed-use estates and Build-to-Rent schemes with leasehold elements.

“Whenever legislation creates unknown future economics, lawyers become more cautious. That can slow transactions.

“But the force for good underpinning this legislation has significant merits.

“First-time buyers may regain confidence in buying flats, particularly in urban markets such as London, Manchester and Birmingham where leasehold flats dominate.

“If commonhold becomes normalised, some see this as a more trusted ownership structure that could expand the pool of willing flat buyers and increase transaction volumes over time.

“It won’t be until several legal challenges emerge that we’ll know if commonhold becomes merely a consumer protection reform or a genuine replacement for leasehold.”

Clear transition timetable needed

Countrywide Surveying Services associate director of technical services Andrew Peters says successful reform will depend on how the new regime is implemented.

He says: “We welcome any government reforms that improve transparency, fairness and homeowner control, while recognising that commonhold represents a significant change for the residential property market.

“The introduction of the Bill provides welcome clarity on the government’s intended direction of travel.

“However, successful reform will depend heavily on the detail of implementation, including strong governance, effective management and sustainable funding for buildings.

“Clear and realistic timescales for commencement and transition will therefore remain critical.

“Any continuing uncertainty around the implementation of leasehold, freehold and commonhold reform risks adding complexity for homeowners, lenders and the wider property market.

“A clear and coordinated implementation pathway will be important in providing confidence and minimising unintended impacts.

“We will continue to work closely with RICS and the wider industry, helping our lender clients understand emerging market evidence, adapt valuation policies and assess risks affecting mortgage security.”

Questions over marriage value rules

The Lease Extension Company founder Tabitha Cumming says the proposals could bring significant benefits for leaseholders but questions remain over how some of the reforms will operate.

She says: “The government’s proposals have the potential to bring some genuinely positive changes for leaseholders.

“Extending statutory lease extensions from 90 to 990 years, abolishing marriage value and making it easier for homeowners to take control of their buildings are all welcome developments.

“Reducing the agreement needed to convert a building to commonhold from 100% to 50% could also be a significant step forward.

“However, while these announcements are encouraging, there’s still a considerable difference between making these promises and delivering them in practice.

“One of the biggest questions is how the government intends to abolish marriage value.

“This can significantly increase the cost of extending a lease once it falls below 80 years, so removing it could save homeowners thousands of pounds.

“But marriage value also represents a financial interest for freeholders, and we still need to see the detail of how the new valuation system will work.

“There is also political uncertainty that shouldn’t be overlooked, with the possibility that some reforms could ultimately be left for a different government to implement.

“That creates uncertainty for leaseholders approaching the 80-year threshold, who face a difficult decision over whether to extend now or wait for reforms that could make the process significantly cheaper.

“The move towards commonhold also raises questions about whether we could see a two-tier property market, with buyers of new-build flats benefiting from a different ownership system while existing leaseholders wait for reforms.

“The Bill still has to pass through both Houses of Parliament, and we need to see the detail of how these changes will work before we can judge their impact.”


More From Life Style